Element's TrueRatings® 2K20 Edition

Element's TrueRatings® 2K20 Edition
0

Out of curiosity I wanted to see how badly 2K is manipulating the ratings of cards this year. Using my spreadsheet method I updated it for the new ratings system. It still does not factor in height, tendencies, or badging, but just based on the attributes you get a ‘real’ overall rating, so you don’t have to rely on the one 2K gives the card for pack-selling purposes. It counts ball-handling more for guards, and rebounding more for bigs, etc. A few examples:

Point Guards

97 Walt Frazier: 94.81
Fully EVO Gilbert Arenas: 94.66
97 Derrick Rose: 93.56
99 Tony Parker: 93.44
97 Gary Payton: 92.27
97 Allen Iverson: 93.24
Fully EVO Jason Kidd: 92.78
97 Stephon Marbury: 91.80
99 Penny Hardaway: 91.17
95 JR Smith: 90.67
95 Donovon Mitchell: 90.36
Fully EVO Jeremy Lin: 90.15
95 Simmons: 90.08
96 Isiah Thomas: 90.04
97 Damian Lillard: 90.04
Fully EVO Isaiah Thomas: 90.00
Fully EVO Rajon Rondo: 89.99
95 Chris Paul: 89.61
95 Oscar Robertson: 88.92
94 John Wall: 88.71
96 James Harden: 88.57
94 Ben Simmons: 87.81
95 Shai Gilgeous-Alexander: 87.43
94 Marcus Smart: 87.25
95 Magic Johnson: 87.12
95 Steph Curry: 85.52
96 Devin Booker: 84.38
88 Ja Morant: 82.82

Shooting Guards

97 Walt Frazier: 95.04
Fully EVO Gilbert Arenas: 95.01
99 Brandon Roy: 94.16
99 Ray Allen: 93.28
99 Dominique Wilkins: 92.85
97 Allen Iverson: 92.98
97 Tracy McGrady: 92.90
95 Michael Jordan: 92.08
95 Donovan Mitchell: 90.94
97 Reggie Lewis: 90.80
95 JR Smith: 90.59
97 Kawhi Leonard: 89.99
Fully EVO DeMar DeRozan: 89.73
94 Paul George: 89.46
95 Jimmy Butler: 88.92
94 Vince Carter: 88.70
97 David Thompson: 87.86
95 Oscar Robertson: 87.64
96 James Harden: 87.52
95 Kobe Bryant: 87.47
95 Danny Granger: 87.41
94 Eddie Jones: 86.93
95 Shai Gilgeous-Alexander: 86.84
93 Jaylen Brown: 86.52
94 Isaiah Rider: 86.02
Fully EVO Terrance Ross: 85.04
96 Devin Booker: 84.15

Small Forwards

Fully EVO Scottie Pippen: 92.01
99 Grant Hill: 91.36
99 Dominique Wilkins: 91.35
97 Carmelo Anthony: 89.94
95 Josh Smith: 89.40
97 Richard Jefferson: 89.14
97 Larry Bird: 88.37
97 James Worthy: 88.34
97 Scottie Pippen: 87.40
97 Paul Millsap: 87.11
95 Giannis Antetekounmpo: 87.03
97 Kawhi Leonard: 86.76
94 Paul George: 86.37
95 Lamar Odom: 86.22
94 Vince Carter: 85.66
95 Jimmy Butler: 85.25
96 Jayson Tatum: 84.42
97 Brandon Ingram: 84.05
95 Pascal Siakam: 83.83
95 Danny Granger: 83.66
95 Andrei Kirilenko: 83.26
94 Isaiah Rider: 83.16
93 Jaylen Brown: 82.25
94 Eddie Jones: 82.19

Power Forwards

Fully EVO Bill Russell: 91.02
95 Josh Smith: 89.45
97 Tim Duncan: 89.01
96 Giannis Antetekounmpo: 88.65
97 Paul Millsap: 88.55
95 Ben Simmons: 88.42
Fully EVO Serge Ibaka: 88.34
95 Anthony Davis: 88.25
97 James Worthy: 88.20
95 Giannis Antetekounmpo: 86.67
97 Chris Bosh: 86.23
97 Blake Griffin: 86.42
94 Ben Simmons: 86.35
97 Serge Ibaka: 86.31
95 Lamar Odom: 86.02
97 Larry Bird: 85.96
95 Pascal Siakam: 84.75
95 Draymond Green: 84.07
97 Kristaps Porzingis: 83.57
95 Andrei Kirilenko: 82.90
97 Brandon Ingram: 81.58

Centers: Shooting

99 David Robinson:: 93.76
Fully EVO Bill Russell: 91.99
97 Hakeem Olajuwon: 91.42
97 Tim Duncan: 90.49
95 Anthony Davis: 89.65
97 Serge Ibaka: 89.54
Fully EVO Bob Pettit: 88.93
99 Arvydas Sabonis: 88.74
Fully EVO Marc Gasol: 88.21
97 Blake Griffin: 88.09
97 Chris Bosh: 88.07
97 Serge Ibaka: 86.63
95 Marc Gasol: 86.52
97 Nikola Jokic: 86.47
97 Kristaps Porzingis: 84.53
91 Magic Johnson: 82.60
94 Brook Lopez: 80.11

Centers: Non-Shooting

97 Hakeem Olajuwon: 92.66
Fully EVO Bill Russell: 92.40
97 Tim Duncan: 90.95
95 Anthony Davis: 90.82
Fully EVO Dwight Howard: 90.46
Fully EVO Serge Ibaka: 90.26
Fully EVO Kareem Abdul-Jabbar: 89.15
97 Serge Ibaka: 87.52
91 Magic Johnson: 83.69

Let me know if you want me to add any cards!

15 Likes

What is the formula for this, how are these being calculated ?

1 Like

91 Magic

I assign a value out of 5 for each attribute, so that part is definitely subjective, but most of them are no brainers like passing accuracy for PG, block for a C, etc. So if the value for passing accuracy is 5, and you have 99 in that attribute, it will pass along a perfect overall rating contribution toward the rating.

93 Outside scoring
91 Shot close 2
89 Shot mid 4
97 Shot 3pt 4
98 Shot IQ
92 Free throw 4
98 Offensive consistency
78 Inside scoring
97 Driving layup 4
25 Standing dunk
36 Driving dunk 2
89 Draw foul 3
35 Post moves
35 Post hook
52 Post fade 1
97 Hands
89 Athleticism
88 Speed 5
91 Acceleration 4
73 Vertical 2
48 Strength 1
98 Stamina
98 Hustle
90 Overall durability
87 Playmaking
88 Speed with ball 5
97 Ball handle 5
93 Passing accuracy 5
72 Passing vision 2
97 Passing IQ 2
79 Defending
30 Interior defense 1
75 Perimeter defense 5
78 Help defense IQ
84 Pick & roll defense IQ
85 Lateral quickness 5
85 Pass perception
97 Reaction time 2
85 Steal 3
47 Block
82 Shot contest 3
65 Defensive consistency 3
54 Rebounding
36 Offensive rebound
61 Defensive rebound

I just paste their rating from 2KMTC into my spreadsheet and the rating is calculated.

6 Likes

That’s for PG ^^

1 Like

At C, I make a distinction between shooting C and non-shooting C. Only because you could have a player with 99 rebounding and 99 block shot but only 70 3PT, if you don’t use your C to shoot 3PT it shouldn’t count against him.

91 Magic Shooting C: 82.60 – Non-Shooting C: 83.69

2 Likes

With the token market update, I need to see C/PG

1 Like

What do you mean? Did they update the card to allow that Amethyst Magic to play PG?? I wouldn’t have noticed, I’m doing this out of curiosity :joy: if that’s the case, this card is 81.63 at PG.

1 Like

I’m curious about Diamond Kobe and PD Iverson

1 Like

Diamond Kobe: 87.47 at SG, 83.98 at SF
PD Iverson: 93.24 at PG, 92.98 at SG

1 Like

What about the opals

1 Like

I wanna see Opal DRob
Please

1 Like

Opal Grant Hill at SF: 91.36
Opal DRob at Shooting C: 93.76
Opal Penny at PG: 91.17

4 Likes

Aye. That’s pretty good.

What’s the highest rating you’ve gotten so far?

1 Like

Looks like DRob is the best. Rose at PG is 93.56

3 Likes

Damn. Wait what’s Diamond Magic?

87.12 at PG

2 Likes

Not bad.

1 Like

It just goes to show that 2K gives card tiers whatever they want and has nothing to do with card quality. It won’t be long before we have rubies that are 90+ in my ratings system.

3 Likes

Check out ruby Ja

1 Like